Naomi Klein has a unique ability to describe a historical moment: When a big swath of humanity has a gut feeling, she can give it expression in the form of a stunning slogan. She did this not just once, with No Logo in 1999, anticipating the emergence of the anti-globalization movement by a few months, but consistently for almost three decades, with similarly gripping books about forever wars (Shock Doctrine), climate change (This Changes Everything / On Fire), the growth of the Far Right (Doppelganger), and more.

Klein’s new work, co-authored with Debt Collective co-founder Astra Taylor, looks at End Times Fascism. Far-right figures like Donald Trump, Jair Bolsonaro, and Marine Le Pen dominate international politics, and leftists argue about what these modern phenomena feed off and how they relate to historical fascism.

As expected, Klein and Taylor offer a handful of brilliant insights. When it emerged in the 1920s, fascism claimed to look toward the future, promising utopias built by thousand-year Reichs. Today’s far-right movements, in contrast, have a simultaneously nostalgic and apocalyptic feel: everything was better in the 1950s, and the world is ending anyway. While capitalists once denied that their system was causing the climate to change, now they welcome the developing catastrophe. As the authors write, today “the smart money is on apocalypse:”

As billionaires have shifted towards the Far Right in the last few years, they make no secret of their belief that their system will destroy itself and all of us in short order. This shift wasn’t caused primarily by pressure tactics from Donald Trump — the billionaires have put all their chips on AI, and a technology so detrimental to both humans and the planet requires more authoritarian politics. Or as the authors put it: “It was AI that made them do it.” To this end, the richest people on the planet have linked up with Christian and Jewish messianism.

Klein and Taylor come up with an appropriately drastic term for these titans who seek to replace humans and escape our planet: they are traitors, not to a particular nation-state, but to humanity itself.

Not Fascism

The book doesn’t ask whether Trump and his ilk represent fascism, treating this as self-evident. “That this is fascism,” the authors write, is now taken for granted by many scholars of authoritarianism.” But is it?

The authors use an entirely ideological definition of fascism, citing its yearning for racial purity etc. They completely ignore the specific social classes that bring fascism to power. This is poor analysis, since fascism has always shown itself to be terribly slippery in terms of ideology. In the same breath, Hitler could promise workers an anti-capitalist revolution while publicly reassuring capitalists that he would crush all workers’ organizations. This inconsistency was of little consequence because the fascist demagogue deliberately appeals to emotions, not to arguments.

What holds fascism together, therefore, is not any kind of consistent worldview, but rather the bundled grievances of the petty bourgeoisie, mobilized in the form of private armies that ultimately serve the interests of capital. That is why fascism is more than just a general term for a right-wing, authoritarian government — there had been, after all, no shortage of right-wing, authoritarian governments before the term fascism had to be invented in the 1920s.

Fascism becomes necessary when capital requires an offensive against the working class and the oppressed, and the bourgeoisie’s normal mechanisms of violent repression (police, courts, etc.) no longer suffice. This is the hour of fascism’s petty-bourgeois private armies that supplement and change the repressive apparatus, disposing of bourgeois democracy.

Klein and Taylor create such a vague definition of fascism that they include the Christian conquest of Al-Andalus in 1492, with which its ethnic cleansing and forced conversions “prefigured elements of the fascist program that would come centuries later.” In that case, it’s hard to say what right-wing government has not been fascist since the emergence of class society. The term fascism dissolves into a catch-all. The authors admit that today’s far-right governments represent  an “uneven” form of fascism that is “partial, incipient, not always dominant or totalizing.” But then even the bourgeois state, which inevitably uses nationalist ideology, becomes “unevenly fascist.”

Today’s increasingly inflationary use of the term fascism can lead to numerous problems, as we’ve argued here again and again. It can lead to sectarian, ultra-left conclusions: If we already live under fascism, then institutions like trade unions must be fascist. But it’s more likely to lead to bourgeois conclusions: liberal politicians like Kamala Harris will throw the f-word around so that we hold our noses and vote for her neoliberal, militaristic program — the alternative, after all is fascism!

Under Trump and other far-right governments, we are witnessing the growth of fascist forces, which often overlap with the state apparatus, such as Proud Boys as part of ICE. The fascist threat is real — but leftists will only disarm ourselves if we proclaim the battle against fascism has already been lost. Governments like those of Trump and Bolsonaro are unstable Bonapartist governments, not fascist regimes that have destroyed all forms of working-class self-organizations.

A Liberal’s Leftist

Klein’s books, in spite of their biting analysis, are inevitably bifurcated: The first half presents a damning condemnation of capitalism’s horrors; the second half, which purports to offer solutions, tends to focus on hyper-local protest movements. If the ruling class is really working for our extinction, will town-hall meetings against data centers be enough?

Klein has always been a liberal’s version of a leftist. She will make asides to socialist ideas — in Doppelganger, for example, she dedicates several pages to the Jewish Trotskyist resistance fighter Abram Leon — but her thinking remains entirely trapped within the confines of capitalism. Klein calls on us to “redistribute the lion’s share of [the oligarchs’] ill-gotten wealth,” for example. But why just a share? What useful role does she think private owners of capital can play that would justify giving them any share? She offers no argument. Capitalism’s fundamental rationality, if a few regulations can be imposed by the state, is taken for granted.

As Max Horkheimer said, “Whoever is not willing to talk about capitalism should also keep quiet about fascism.” The way to beat fascism for good is by expropriating the bourgeoisie. Yet Klein and Taylor present “multiracial social democracy” as “the ultimate threat to end times fascism.”

The book’s strongest chapter covers the Minneapolis uprising against ICE terror. Workers developed elementary forms of self-organization to protect and provide for their neighbors — they showed rough outlines of how the city could be organized in a radically different way, in opposition to the capitalist state. Yet Klein and Taylor present these protests more like a prequel to progressive administrations from the Democratic Party.

In fact, the entire conclusion of the book reads like a long campaign ad for Zohran Mamdani. He wins praise not just for the relatively minor reforms he has passed, but also for his willingness to work with Zionists. It’s not clear if Klein and Taylor explicitly support his decision to keep the far-right Zionist billionaire Jessica Tisch in her post as NYPD commissioner, but that’s the strong implication. They laud him for working with Kathy Hochul, the Democratic governor of New York State.

This book’s anti-fascist role model is Franklin Delano Roosevelt. But his New Deal was very explicitly a program intended to save capitalism from the threat of workers’ revolution. And it was successful. Roosevelt’s administration did not ultimately vanquish fascism. The New Deal created a hegemonic imperialist power that installed and backed numerous right-wing, repressive governments around the world. By maintaining the capitalist system, combined with certain reforms intended to win consent from broader sectors, the New Deal prepared the ground for the resurgence of fascist movements we see today.

The real threat to fascism, as any fascist will tell you, is communism. It is by expropriating (not just taxing) the capitalist class that we can defeat the fascist threat once and for all, and begin the urgent task of completely reorganizing the global economy in order to save as much of human civilization as we can.

The post Neither What Fascism Is Nor How to Fight It: A Marxist Take on Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor’s New Book appeared first on Left Voice.


From Left Voice via This RSS Feed.