Make a one-time donation to The Ditch

In early November 2019 I got a 6pm flight from Beijing to Dublin. I landed and got my bags and handed them off to my mum, along with the four grand in cash I’d almost legally changed from yuan to Euro. I got on another flight to Lisbon for Web Summit.
I was in the speakers’ area at the event and got chatting to an editor at Politico, publication of record for the promotion of European values, penance for spending the last year in China.
He was English. So he had to talk about Brexit. I told him, look, I’m no fan of the EU. Why aren’t you a fan of the EU? I’m a socialist. So? Well the EU is a neoliberal project… Eyes narrowing, he asked, “How is it neoliberal?” How did the Magi find the Christ child in the manger, like Tom Waits asked, how indeed?
We went back and forth, but it always came back to Brexit, still does for these people. I told him that despite my personal opposition to the EU, were a referendum called in Ireland, driven by the same politics that took Britain out, I’d probably vote to remain. Seven years later, grown a bit, three years of EU support for genocide in Palestine, I don’t equivocate like that.
That four grand or so came from the Publicity Department of the Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party. Another name for it: the Central Propaganda Department.
The department owns and manages China Daily, the paper I’d worked for as a journalist and editor alongside western and Chinese staff. Management encouraged a divide between us. They didn’t fully trust us westerners. This frustrated an American friend at the paper who just wanted to play his part. He wanted to help the Central Propaganda Department produce, in his own words, better propaganda. And why not, it’s not a bad word.
I remember talking with him when editors were deciding whether to publish a negative opinion piece I’d written about the EU. “We’re not yet a month into 2019 and already over 200 migrants have died trying to reach Europe via the Mediterranean Sea,” I’d written.
If China Daily had published the article it would, I suppose, have been Chinese propaganda. They didn’t. My American colleague speculated that China’s trade relationship with the EU might’ve been a factor. Maybe he was right, that it wasn’t the right propaganda for the Chinese state. Maybe it just wasn’t any good. What is that line now, written for China Daily but published on The Ditch: still Chinese propaganda? Political commentary? Still not any good?
Bad media, bad countries
So I have experience working in bad – says the west – state media in a bad – says the west – country. That country paid my salary. I consider it part of my time in journalism. As I’ve written before I don’t feel the need to disavow it. I wouldn’t though.
I don’t think it’s possible, intellectually or politically or philosophically, to come up with a definition of journalism that includes everyone you consider legitimate and excludes everyone you don’t. You can try but I think you’re better off, for consistency, to be broad: the publication or broadcast of news for public consumption. In Ireland there are at least 750 million obstacles to making the case that the state paying your salary means you’re not a journalist.
Chay Bowes, another who’s worked in state media, is a co-founder of The Ditch. It didn’t work out with us and Chay. There’s not much else to it. Chay, Roman Shortall and I disagreed on too much, politically and strategically, for us to work well together. So we broke. That was more than four years ago, in summer 2022, and it was the right move for us. We all ended up doing what we wanted.
I condemn the European Union’s sanctions on him.
“Chay Bowes,” reads the Council of the EU’s announcement of the sanctions, “is an Irish citizen working as a correspondent for the Russian transnational influence channel RT International. He has been the host of a RT TV show called ‘Moscow Mules’ since February 2024.”
As pointed out by Harry Browne on The Ditch: The Party Line, some disagree that Chay is a journalist. That’s fine, though I doubt they’d be able to articulate a set of principles that doesn’t inadvertently include other journalists they respect. The EU isn’t among these people questioning whether Chay is a journalist. To the union he’s a correspondent at RT.
He’s a correspondent who is also, according to the sanctions, “planning, directing, engaging in, directly or indirectly, supporting or otherwise facilitating the use of coordinated information manipulation and interference”. They say he’s involved in Russian state misinformation campaigns linked to the Wagner Group and what’s known as Storm-1516. Chay denies this part and Irish media have mostly qualified claims he’s a propagandist with an alleged or allegedly: “Chay Bowes put on EU sanctions list for allegedly spreading Russian ‘propaganda’,” said the Irish Times; “Irish journalist Chay Bowes has been sanctioned by the EU as an alleged propagandist for the Russian government,” said RTÉ.
We are to believe this propaganda, alleged or otherwise, threatens the EU. “He is therefore implementing, supporting and facilitating actions or policies attributable to the Government of the Russian Federation which undermine or threaten democracy, the rule of law, stability or security in the Union,” reads the announcement.
Is European democracy so fragile? Europe, neither the continent nor union, is at war with Russia, no matter how much our arms industry and its boosters in parliaments and media want it to be. The idea that we are is popular though.
It’s on this idea that so much around us is predicated: government’s plans to abolish the triple lock; the invitations to arms lobbyists from our national media; the tortuous debates over whether Catherine Connolly clapped for Volodymyr Zelensky in the Dáil. The inverse of what Chay is accused of promoting is ambient noise.
The Ditch: aberrant and deviant
RT is already banned in Europe, so we’re talking about Chay’s Twitter account, now at more than 300,000 followers. I’m one of them. I don’t rely on the account for coverage of the war in Ukraine. I also don’t think its contents undermine the foundations of European society.
European elites do a good job of threatening European democracy, rule of law, stability and security. They don’t need Chay to help. Unlike the European ruling class Chay Bowes hasn’t: coerced the Irish state into €64 billion of debt to save the continent’s financial industry; drowned thousands in the Mediterranean Sea; funded genocide in Palestine; called Trump daddy.
Because of his work and the positions he’s taken, European bureaucracy, along with the tacit approval of the Irish state, has decided to fully delegitimise him. I’m not immune to that type of thinking.
Just before Christmas 2021 Chay came to Roman and me with an idea. He wanted to take Fianna Fáil to court over its annual lottery, transparently a means for the party to get around political donations legislation. I thought it was a bad idea. I balked, said I couldn’t stop him going ahead with it but that The Ditch wouldn’t be involved. I was tired of The Chay Bowes Show (now the name of one of his podcasts) and I think I allowed my misgivings about our still-substantive political differences to influence my judgement. I was, obviously, wrong. Chay successfully took the case. It embarrassed Fianna Fáil and Micheál Martin.
The differences and disagreements between us and Chay didn’t matter to Martin when, almost a year after Chay had resigned his directorship at Ditch Media Ltd and signed away his shares, the then tánaiste abused Dáil privilege to suggest The Ditch was, if not a Russian influence operation, certainly adjacent to one. The purpose was to designate The Ditch as aberrant and deviant, on the wrong side of the border, unacceptable. It worked, with some.
Martin loves power. Paradoxically he also loves deferring to authority. That’s what he’s done in reaction to the sanctions on Chay. “I would invite people to read themselves and it’s fairly clear,” he said. “People don’t end up on a sanctions list other than for very good reasons in respect of being part of the wider Russian propaganda scene.”
These very good reasons share a repressive politics with the US sanctioning of Francesca Albanese for her advocacy of international law. They align with the indictment of Daithi O’Corrain for his alleged destruction of $60 million of US government property, an Air National Guard C-130 Hercules warplane parked on the runway at Shannon Airport. Foreign affairs minister Helen McEntee said, “If you meet that criteria and you’re put on a sanctions list, then we’re going to support that”. Junior minister Neale Richmond posted a muscle emoji. Their responses come from the same place that led An Garda Síochána to raid the Dublin home of pro-Palestinian activist Fergie Chambers on the orders of the Trump administration this week.
The week Micheál Martin said his piece about The Ditch in the Dáil a few journalists got in touch to ask for our reaction. Colm Keena in the Irish Times published one of the first pieces. He led with an interview he’d done with Chay. I was raging. Here was the guy, used to discredit us, inserting himself, discrediting us. It was annoying at the time but I can see now that it wasn’t our real problem. The issue is that we’ve abdicated to the likes of Micheál Martin, along with those he defers to in Brussels, the right to decide what is and isn’t legitimate.
Make a one-time donation to The Ditch
From The Ditch via This RSS Feed.


