
This story was originally published by The Imprint, a national nonprofit news outlet covering child welfare and youth justice. Sign up for The Imprint’s free newsletters here.
Nancy Marie Spears
The Imprint
Foster care placement guidelines under the 1978 Indian Child Welfare Act require that Indigenous children removed from home by a social worker be placed with a family member, a member of the child’s tribe or another Indigenous family whenever possible. But that’s often not happening in most states, according to research published in the Children and Youth Services Review this month.
The study was co-authored by Theresa Rocha Beardall, associate professor of sociology at the University of Washington, and Frank Edwards, associate professor of criminal justice at Rutgers University.
Their research revealed that about half of Native foster children nationwide went to Native homes. There were pronounced differences across states. Some places achieved kinship placements for more than 60 percent of ICWA-eligible children, but many others fell far short of the goal.
Edwards said he’s not aware of any prior studies examining how well ICWA placement preferences are being followed.
Most interesting, he said, was that “even in those states where we see a relatively high level of compliance, we still see a lot of kids in placement settings that are not consistent with the preferences laid out in ICWA.”
The study analyzed Adoption and Foster Care Analysis and Reporting System (AFCARS) data from 2018 to 2023 to identify children’s placements with Indigenous relatives or foster parents. Authors estimated how likely Native children are to enter “preferred placements” under ICWA nationally and by state, compared to kin placements.
Eight states placed half or more than half of Native children in foster homes that met ICWA standards. And in 43 states, less than half of foster children were moved into placements with kin or Native foster homes, according to the study. Additionally, ICWA-preferred placement rates decline as children get older — infants are far more likely than teenagers to be in such placements**.**
Rocha Beardall said in a Nov. 16 press release that improving tribal children’s outcomes will require “accountability structures that ensure that compliance is not merely aspirational but achieved in the daily operations of child welfare systems serving Native children and families.”
When entering foster care, American Indian and Alaska Native infants were most likely to be moved into relatives’ homes in Arizona, Maryland, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Florida, and North Carolina**,** the researchers found. They were least likely to be placed with kin in Delaware, Tennessee, Virginia, Georgia, Massachusetts, South Carolina, Arkansas, and Kentucky.
By comparison, Arizona was the only state where at least half of all foster children went to the homes of kin.
Nationally, Black children are the least likely group of children to live with kin while in foster care, while Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander children are the most likely. Between 2018 and 2023, Native and white children were placed with kin at similar rates, the study states.
Edwards said one of the study’s limitations stems from its use of federal data, which tracks the population of Native children in state foster care systems, but does not currently track how many Indigenous foster children are eligible for ICWA protections because they are members of tribes or eligible for membership. And the limited data the national database keeps on Native children in tribal systems is restricted to the eight tribes who share numbers with the government.
That could change in 2028, when the federal government will start tracking numerous metrics involving states’ ICWA compliance.
“Once we get the new AFCARS data, it’ll be a first opportunity to directly look at compliance — we just don’t have that data right now,” Edwards said. The result is a patchwork performance across the country.
“That’s a problem that will require federal work at some point,” Edwards added, “to either institute penalties for failure to comply or to institute incentives when states can demonstrate they are complying.”
The post States fall short of foster care placement requirements for Tribal children, study finds appeared first on ICT.
From ICT via This RSS Feed.


