
A federal court in New York has scheduled a new hearing for December 17, 2026, to consider arguments by Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro’s legal team that the criminal case against him should be dismissed on grounds of foreign sovereign immunity.
The decision was made by Judge Analisa Torres of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, who took over the case following the death of Judge Alvin Hellerstein. It came after President Maduro’s attorneys, Barry J. Pollack and Anna Estevao, filed a 72-page memorandum on November 9 asking the court to dismiss the case “with prejudice.”
The session will examine a request from Maduro’s legal team for the definitive dismissal of the charges under the doctrine of foreign sovereign immunity.
RELATED: New Judge Named in President Maduro’s Trial After Hellerstein Death
Along with the December hearing, Torres authorized on November 16 that certain exhibits remain under seal, while a redacted version of the main document circulates.
In its filing, the defense invokes both head-of-state immunity, arguing Nicolas Maduro was a sitting President when he was kidnapped on January 3, and functional immunity for official acts. It stresses that U.S. prosecutors themselves acknowledge that Nicolas Maduro assumed the presidency through constitutional succession in 2013 and continued exercising executive powers after 2019.
Washington’s Contradictions
The memorandum argues that the effective exercise of power is enough to trigger immunity, regardless of Washington’s political narratives. It notes that the White House kept direct channels of communication with President Maduro after the 2019 rupture, including a January 2025 visit to Caracas by special envoy Richard Grenell and a phone call with President Donald Trump later that year.
The lawyers also point out that the UN General Assembly approved the credentials of the Venezuelan government at every session since 2019. In December 2025, they say, only Ecuador, Argentina, Peru and Paraguay backed the U.S.-promoted objection.
Ver esta publicación en Instagram
Una publicación compartida de Nicolás Maduro (@nicolasmaduro)
On the domestic front, the document says that after the events of January 3, the Constitutional Chamber of Venezuela’s Supreme Court assigned the Acting presidency to Delcy Rodríguez without declaring an absolute absence of the President. The defense calls “illogical” the U.S. position of recognizing and restoring ties with Rodríguez even though she was elected Vice-president in the same vote that Washington disputes.
The attorneys further stressed that Venezuela never waived its sovereign immunity, as Ambassador Samuel Moncada stated on January 5 before the U.N. Security Council. They also challenged charges based on official acts and a recycled conspiracy-to-commit-torture count added on October 6. Both President Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores, have pleaded “not guilty.”
The December 17 hearing is expected to be key in deciding how far the principle of sovereign immunity for heads of state applies to the U.S. effort to try the Venezuelan leader in its domestic courts.
From teleSUR English via This RSS Feed.

