![]()
As they say: fish gonna swim, birds gonna fly, and a Labour government gonna try to implement some kind of workfare scheme which benefits corporations. This week’s headlines were dominated by Alan Milburn, one of Tony Blair’s ministerial stalwarts, and his report into the state of Britain’s NEETs (those not in employment, education, or training). Milburn recommended that the government abolish the health component of universal credit for under-25s, and replace PIP payments for under-25s with a new “additional cost allowance”. Cynics amongst you may quibble with the idea that it’s the benefits system stopping young people from entering work, as opposed to, say, the recent bonfire of entry-level jobs.
In any case, Milburn has been rewarded for his contributions with an appointment to chair of the new Youth Opportunities Unit, reporting directly to the prime minister. Well, it’s nice to know that somebody’s out there finding work.
The Cortado
Get your shot of political analysis from Ash Sarkar and Steven Methven, every Monday and Friday morning.
First name:
Email:
I agree to the Privacy Policy
Sign up error: . Try again later.
Thanks for signing up.
It’s undeniable that young people are getting screwed over. The youth share of the labour market has gone down, even as employment overall has gone up. While the headline percentage of NEETs hasn’t changed drastically in the last 20 years, the composition of NEETs has. In 2005, four in ten young NEETs had never had a job. Now, it’s six in ten. A young person first claiming health and disability benefits in 2019 is a third more likely, in five years time, to still be out of employment, education or training, than those who first claimed in 2010. NEETdom is stickier than it used to be, as is joblessness as a result of ill health.
To be fair to Milburn, he isn’t saying it’s all young people’s fault. His interim report, released earlier this year, acknowledged that recruitment has become “more remote, more automated and less human”. Print this out, and show it to your Dad who says you just need to get out there and hand out CVs: “The young person who once might have walked into a shop, spoken to a manager and been given a chance in the past is now screened by a portal, a test, a recorded interview or an algorithm before anyone has looked them in the eye.”
And yet, taking the government’s sunny line on the advantages of AI, Milburn’s report insists that it’s “wrong to blame AI for the recent rise in youth detachment”. Cool, fine, let’s just ignore what research and business leaders have to say about the specific role of AI in cutting entry level jobs. But in case you were worried that Milburn wasn’t taking the threat of AI to young people’s jobs seriously enough, he does propose setting up “a small AI Youth Observatory” whose remit is tracking “changes in youth recruitment, entry-level tasks and occupations by sector and place”. That sounds nice and urgent.
Beyond cutting benefits and establishing yet another quango, Milburn’s work has prompted the government to set up a youth job creation scheme. It promises guaranteed jobs for young people on universal credit, and vows to support over 90,000 young people furthest from work into a role. The state will fully fund up to 25 hours of paid work a week for six months, at the relevant minimum wage, and 400 employers, including Lidl, Leonardo Hotels and Boots have already signed on.
So, instead of using government money to fund socially useful jobs – insulating homes or planting trees, for instance – taxpayers are paying Boots to help young NEETs flog tingle-sensation lube.
Milburn’s report urges the government to go further, recommending that employer national insurance contributions for workers aged 21 to 24 (starting in the retail and hospitality sectors) are lowered over five years. As Private Eye has pointed out, the majority-owner of the Burger King UK ‘master franchise’ is an investment management firm that Milburn just happens to advise and be a shareholder in.
Funny how the biggest beneficiaries of government spending turn out to be corporations.
From Novara Media via This RSS Feed.


