(FILE) Argentinian Supreme Court. Photo: EFE.

Argentina’s Supreme Court declared unconstitutional two articles of emergency decree (DNU) 70/2023 promoted by President Javier Milei that allowed private health insurance companies to set their premiums freely, and ordered the State to reassume its powers of oversight and authorization over increases.


On Thursday, November 19, the court struck down articles 267 and 269, finding that the Executive Branch neither proved the exceptional circumstances required by the Constitution nor justified the necessity and urgency needed to eliminate state controls over private health coverage prices. Returning to its doctrine on constitutional limits, it held that this route is permissible only under rigorous exceptionality—when ordinary parliamentary procedure is impossible or an emergency is incompatible with normal legislative timeframes.

RELATED: Argentina Abstains in UN Vote on Violence Against Women, Sides With U.S.

The ruling rejected the government’s justification, which rested on a health system crisis and the need to boost competitiveness. The court held that such generic considerations do not minimally demonstrate a situation so urgent that it must be addressed within a timeframe incompatible with the normal legislative process.

Pensioners’ organizations in Rosario announced a Wednesday march to demand higher retirement benefits, improved health care coverage, and the restoration of social security rights amid mounting concerns about declining purchasing power and barriers to accessing pensions.

The… pic.twitter.com/bU5KcIqweA

— teleSUR English (@telesurenglish) November 18, 2026

With the annulment, two mechanisms of Law 26.682 that the decree had eliminated take effect again: the implementing authority’s power to review premium values and their modifications, and the State’s duty to oversee and guarantee reasonable prices. Companies can no longer set premiums freely, and any adjustment requires authorization based on cost structure variations and a reasonable risk calculation.

The ruling clarified that it applies strictly to the challenged articles and expresses no opinion on the constitutional validity of the rest of DNU 70/2023, which deregulates broad areas of the economy. The decision resolves an amparo action filed by a member against Swiss Medical after her premium rose 110% between December 2023 and February 2024, when the decree took effect in the first month of Milei’s term; she argued that under the prior scheme the January 2024 increase would have been 6.26%. The claim was rejected at first instance, but the Federal Court of Appeals of La Plata revoked that ruling, declared both articles unconstitutional and ordered increases capped at the consumer price index percentage, prompting appeals by both Swiss Medical and the State that led to the Supreme Court’s intervention.


From teleSUR English via This RSS Feed.