The scene: two Left Voice authors and a visiting family member sit down around 9pm to watch Alex Gibney’s nearly four hour-long Musk documentary. Our family member has to get up at five to catch her train home, and I tend to doze off around 10:30 no matter my intentions, so we plan to watch the first half together, then finish the movie separately and text about it.

The reality: We do not pause the movie at intermission, and we say goodnight around 1:30.

The movie begins with a voiceover from Gibney explaining that Musk refused to be interviewed for the documentary, and anticipates that it will be a hit piece. We see screenshots of them exchanging barbs on Twitter. Gibney instead has his team assemble a database of publicly-available clips from Musk’s other interviews, some of which are included as-is in the film, and others have their audio harvested and spoken from the mouth of an AI-generated Musk avatar, which functions as a talking head (literally, the head is uncannily large).

Near the beginning of the film, Gibney says the question he set out to answer was, how can one man, this man, amass so much power? Some answers posed by the movie: family money, luck, the abundance of venture capital money during the dot com bubble, screwing over business partners, the exploitation of workers, lies, NDAs, the privatization of work previously done by government agencies (thanks Obama), and most of all, money begets more money, which begets power.

Because the movie is a deep dive into just one superwealthy man’s story, it does not address bigger ideas of how the very nature of a capitalist economy not only allows Musk-like figures to emerge, but guarantees it. While all of those above factors contribute to Elon Musk’s individual story — and there’s much to learn and loathe about that individual story — the fact remains that we have an economy where wealth is funnelled to the top, and our laws are designed to privilege those who own businesses, land, and other forms of wealth, as Musk’s particular story illustrates.

The documentary is organized into all of the various chronological and thematic chapters one might expect: Tesla, SpaceX, Covid, the takeover and gutting of Twitter, DOGE, Starlink and Ukraine, his upbringing, his treatment of his partners (both business and romantic) and children, the scandal around Musk allowing Grok to generate sexually explicit materials of real people, and so on. While many of these chapters could have gone deeper into the issue (if the movie wasn’t already approaching four hours), the only key moment I can think of that isn’t discussed is his role in promoting (and one might assume also influencing, behind the scenes) U.S. imperialism to procure favorable conditions for mining rare earth minerals, a la “we can coup whoever we want” in Bolivia.

Despite being so long, the movie flew by for us. Each segment is engaging — there are just simply so many segments. I was the most Musk-knowledgeable among the three of us, and while I knew most of the headlines of each section, I appreciated learning more about the particularities (especially the horrific examples of Tesla autopilot failures) and hearing more of Ashley St. Clair’s story, and my companions found the movie both educational and enraging.

The AI Musk throughout the film is deeply unsettling — and that’s the point, I think. Sure, there’s a “haha, gotcha” element to making an AI mogul appear in a film without his consent using the type of tool he promotes, but it’s also a recurring reminder of the threat AI video generation poses to us all.

Another unsettling editing choice is the use of video game-style effects at various points — especially in a first person shooter-style animation of Musk electrocuting Twitter employees (symbolizing the harsh layoffs) and chainsawing federal employees during the DOGE chapter (a reference to the engraved chainsaw gifted to him by Milei). The idea is that Musk treats workers like NPCs, and we should all be disturbed by it.

I was surprised to see that Jacobin’s Eileen Jones had written such a negative review of the film. Her title, “Even Musk Haters Will Hate Sitting Through Musk” was certainly not true in my home, and I do think she overestimates the extent to which people who already hate Musk already know all or even most of the details discussed in the film (although she may be right that most of these people don’t want four hours of it). She sees the AI-Musk and the video game stylings as heavy-handed and cringeworthy, which I respectfully disagree with. On the other hand, I think her most valid criticism is that many of the video and audio clips gathered from elsewhere go uncited and decontextualized.

Jones’s criticism that I disagree with the most, though, is that the unavoidable message of the film is doomerism. I think Gibney avoiding the question of what to do is different from arguing that nothing can be done. Jones and I also differ in that her review was published on October 20, and I watched the movie after the midterms. I – and every future viewer – watched the movie already knowing that Musk’s $500 million investment in the midterms failed, that tech stocks are falling, and that almost every ballot measure aimed at stopping, stalling, or limiting data center construction passed.

That’s not to say a blue tsunami is the answer to how to stop Musk – it’s not, of course. He remains extremely powerful, and capitalist politicians from both parties are incentivized to treat the tech companies with a light touch, when SpaceX and Starlink in particular are deeply integrated into infrastructures relative to U.S. interests both domestically and internationally and the vast majority of recent U.S. economic growth relies on the tech industry. But the midterms do break the illusion that Musk is invulnerable — that everything will always go his way.

At my house, the takeaway from Musk was not despair, but fury. And in a month where it seems like everyone, including much of the Left, is joyfully libbing out, a return to class rage is especially important.

The post In a Week of “Libbing Out,” Musk Documentary Offers Class Rage appeared first on Left Voice.


From Left Voice via This RSS Feed.