Make a one-time donation to The Ditch

State report on medical failures at Children's Health Ireland set to be a 'whitewash'

Government is planning a “whitewash” of the state’s failures in children’s healthcare – including putting young people through unnecessary surgery – according to an advocacy group representing children with spinal disabilities.

Co-lead of the Spina Bifida and Hydrocephalus Paediatric Advocacy Group Úna Keightley told The Ditch that health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and tánaiste Simon Harris have reneged on previous commitments to families failed by Children’s Health Ireland (CHI).

In September 2023 The Ditch reported that unlicensed implants had been used in spinal operations on children at CHI’s Temple Street hospital. In February 2025 The Ditch obtained a leaked expert report that found nearly 80 percent of hip operations at a CHI hospital were unnecessary.

Affected families want a public inquiry but the state is resisting.

“The department’s own meeting minutes stated that there would be a statutory inquiry – a tribunal,” said Keightley. “And that there would be an independent mediator agreed by both sides to tease out what should be looked into in the inquiry. Instead Jennifer Carroll MacNeill got her own person and sent him off with a really narrow job description, which resulted in a proposal for a really narrow inquiry.”

Senior counsel Remy Farrell, appointed by MacNeill, has proposed a commission of investigation rather than tribunal. Elements of commissions take place in private settings, unlike tribunals, which are held in public and take longer to complete. Keightley says the process is designed to protect the people it should be examining.

“It’s allowing certain things to take place behind closed doors, with written submissions.That suits the doctors who caused harm to children. It suits the management. It suits the government,” she said. “At the heart of what the state is proposing is an administrative review. It’s just a whitewash.”

The Spina Bifida and Hydrocephalus Paediatric Advocacy Group briefed Leinster House this evening, hosted by Senator Tom Clonan.

Keightley spoke alongside Amanda Coughlan and Claire Cahill, co-founder of the Scoliosis Advocacy Network.

The Spina Bifida and Hydrocephalus Paediatric Advocacy Group and others impacted by medical practices at CHI are calling on TDs to support the appointment of an independent mediator and for the Dáil vote on the inquiry’s terms of reference to be a free vote.

“It shouldn’t be the party whip telling the TDs how to vote,” Keightley said. “We’re asking the TDs to do the right thing – not stand by the institutions that failed our children.”

Make a one-time donation to The Ditch


From The Ditch via This RSS Feed.