When Cuba’s National Assembly met on July 30 in order to unanimously approve 176 market reforms after just one week of “debate,” the government declared that these economic transformations are being carried out “without compromising our independence, national sovereignty, or the social gains of the Revolution.” They seem to be ignoring the fact that independence and national sovereignty cannot simply be declared while everything is being done to undermine them.
Opening up the island to foreign investment and privatizing key sectors of the economy are not ways to advance toward socialism, but rather to retreat toward capitalism. The only project that can guarantee Cuba’s independence is proletarian revolution.
The question of independence takes on greater importance after the events in Venezuela. That country has been reduced to a protectorate after the U.S. abducted President Nicolás Maduro and his wife, Cilia Flores. At this moment, Marco Rubio controls Venezuela’s top leadership via text messages while stealing the Bolivarian nation’s oil.
An Independent Cuba
Cuba’s struggle for independence has been going on for centuries: from Indigenous uprisings and slave revolts to struggles against the Spanish Crown and the revolutions of 1933 and 1959. Cuba’s independence is no minor question — the idea inspired movements that drew in millions of people. What does an independent Cuba mean today?
The imperialists love to celebrate May 20, 1902, the day the Republic of Cuba was founded. That republic was shackled, controlled, and subject to imperialist restrictions by the United States. Spain was no longer the colonizer — Cuba had acquired a new master. It would take another 57 years to win Cuba’s genuine independence, not just in theory but also in practice.
Freedom is a complicated thing but also quite simple. Throughout our history, we have come to understand what each oppressor considered freedom to be. Can a person be free on paper if they have no way to exercise that freedom? Is a person free if they cannot read or if they cannot protect their children’s health, as was the case in pre-revolutionary Cuba?
As Fidel Castro said at the U.N. General Assembly in 1960, “there can be no political independence unless there is economic independence,” and “political independence without economic independence is a lie.”
Cuba only achieved its freedom after expropriating the means of production, which, since they were controlled by large foreign corporations, did not serve the interests of the people. These companies were taken over and put to work not in the interests of capital, but to satisfy social needs. The local bourgeoisie did everything in its power to prevent this struggle from advancing. It always looks out for its class interests and inevitably makes alliances with the more powerful bourgeoisie across the sea.
That is what the Russian revolutionary Leon Trotsky outlined in his premises of the theory of permanent revolution. In economically backward countries, only the working class can carry out the task of securing national independence. The national bourgeoisie is incapable of leading this struggle.
But it is not enough to destroy the capitalist class. The means of production, once expropriated, must be placed in the hands of the workers so that they can plan the economy through proletarian democracy. It is impossible to believe that, with such a powerful education system, Cuba has any need for a select group of bureaucrats to make all the decisions required by the people and the revolution.
At the same time, it is impossible to imagine an independent Cuba without allies; independence cannot be secured in isolation. It is of vital importance to develop workers’ movements internationally and particularly in Latin America, where all oppressed people have similar interests in relation to the national bourgeoisie and imperialism.
A Socialist Perspective for Workers’ Democracy
The socialist revolution is not posed in abstract or moralistic terms, but concretely in terms of the people’s needs — in the same way that independence was conceived in practical terms by all those who suffered, fought, and died for it.
It is crucial to note that not all the ills afflicting Cuba today stem from imperialism, which spares no effort to increase the people’s suffering. Another internal obstacle to the development of socialism in Cuba — one that helps explain the current profound social crisis — is the bureaucracy. It is a bureaucracy that rules without popular input, represses independent left-wing movements, opens the door to capitalism while calling it socialism, and does everything possible to enrich the new bourgeoisie, while completely ignoring the vast majority of the people.
Cuba was once internationally renowned for its social services, but these have almost completely been destroyed. Children lack schools and families lack health care. Private pharmacies and nursing homes have emerged, while little is said about those who cannot afford to pay — their situations are barely reflected in the statistics. The immense rage that brought down the Batista regime is now turning against Díaz-Canel. This is hardly surprising; it would be hard to imagine anyone in the president’s shoes being so indifferent to the people’s endless suffering. One wonders whether a new version of [Fidel Castro’s famous courtroom defense] History Will Absolve Me is needed to defend the pot-banging protests that have taken place across the country for months.
It is crucial to support radical left movements in Cuba. A socialist perspective is needed — one that pushes for workers’ democracy. There are countless tasks to take up and years of accumulated discontent to fuel the struggle. The challenge is enormous, the living conditions are unbearable, and the repression is relentless. Only an opposition that breaks with the PCC and its logic of capitalist restoration, while remaining implacable toward imperialism, can succeed. Our only hope lies with working people, not with the bureaucracy or with imperialism.
First published in Spanish on November 17 on La Izquierda Diario
Translation by Nathaniel Flakin
The post Can Cuba Be Independent Under Capitalism? appeared first on Left Voice.
From Left Voice via This RSS Feed.


