“These rights have primacy in all constitutional rights. This is the highest constitutional right that the government should protect at all cost.”

As police continue to block protesters from different places using checkpoints, progressive lawyers said the police are interrupting not only the rights of the people to protest but also of Filipinos who are working during the 49th ASEAN Summit.

Delegates from Southern Tagalog who held the Lakbayan ng Timog Katalugan (Southern Tagalog caravan) starting on November 12, faced police brutality during their march to Liwasang Bonifacio.

Previously, they have been repeatedly blocked by police forces. Reports from UPLB Perspective shows punctured tires from the vehicles used by the delegates. The harassment continued where police disrupted the delegates when they barricaded the road at midnight to prevent them from moving forward.

On November 15, police brutality took over as they violently arrested almost 270 delegates while holding a peaceful mobilization. As of this writing, the National Union of People’s Lawyers and Koalisyong Makabayan have gained access to those arrested.

In the University of the Philippines, hundreds of police were deployed to man checkpoints at the exit points. The PICC and nearby areas were also heavily guarded. Aside from these checkpoints, there are also other checkpoints conducted in the borders of several provinces and the National Capital Region.

In an interview, National Union of Peoples’ Lawyer (NUPL) Ephraim “Rey” Cortez underscores that mass deployment of checkpoints within the area violates freedom of expression and right to peaceful assembly that is protected under the Philippine constitution.

“These rights have primacy in all constitutional rights. This is the highest constitutional right that the government should protect at all cost,” Cortez asserted.

Cortez also explained that freedom of expression should include the right of people to protest not just in any designated freedom park such as the Liwasang Bonifacio but anywhere without needing to secure a permit.

In Batas Pambansa Bldg. 880, going to freedom park to protest does not need a permit or any travel pass. Lawyers like the NUPL argue that blocking protesters while officials cannot identify clear and present danger is unconstitutional.

The said law has been facing criticism by NUPL stating that “this dictatorship-era law that places constitutional rights of the people to collective action under a system of prior state approval.”

Aside from rally permit arguments, Cortez added that traffic regulations should not also be used as a tool to suppress or stop the people going to freedom park where they can protest to amplify their call against police brutality and opposition to Pax Silica where thousands of Ayta and local farmers will lose their livelihood.

“As long as there is no clear and present danger, [it] cannot prevail over the exercise of constitutional guaranteed rights,” Cortez explained.

As there are no specific laws on checkpoints, the Supreme Court has previous decisions such as the Valmonte vs. De Villa, which states that checkpoint is not illegal but law enforcement shall be limited to visual search.

In Aniag Jr. vs COMELEC, it is stated that police should only have access to a vehicle if they have probable cause or voluntary consent. None of the ruling states that checkpoints can be used to block protesters, especially going to freedom park.

“You are conducting a checkpoint because there is an impending criminal act to be committed. But if the checkpoint is used because of protest, it violates their constitutional rights […] You can’t put the blame on protesters as they are continuously moving and exercising their rights,” Cortez said.

According to Cortez, it is not the people who participated in the rally causing traffic, the blame should fall on the police who continuously block the protesters’ way to raise their legitimate concerns.

As police brutality continues, progressive groups vow to push through with their protests to amplify the call of the marginalized groups especially to Indigenous and local communities who will be affected once the Pax Silica is officially constructed. (AMU, RVO)

The post ‘Unconstitutional’ — lawyers on checkpoints blocking, delaying protesters appeared first on Bulatlat.


From Bulatlat via This RSS Feed.