On Monday, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced highly anticipated plans to overhaul the structure of the New York Police Department’s repressive Strategic Response Group (SRG).

In a pre-recorded video with City Council Member Chi Ossé published on Monday morning Mamdani said, “New Yorkers exercising their constitutional right to protest should not be met with the same police response as a terrorism threat. We are establishing a new, civilian-led approach that prioritizes dialogue, engagement and de-escalation.”

The announcement follows months of increasing pressure from Mamdani supporters and the broader Left to get rid of the counter-terrorism and civil unrest unit, which has been used by three different mayors to crush protest and punish dissent in the city for more than a decade.

Unfortunately, despite the Mayor’s rhetoric his proposal is nothing but a classic bait and switch operation. The proposal gets rid of the SRG in name only, replacing it with a different repressive force, and will do nothing to protect protesters from further police repression. Like a used car salesman, the mayor has lured his supporters in with a shiny promise to get rid of the SRG, but instead sold them on a stripped down plan that merely obscures the coercive power of the police while doing nothing to protect the interests or increase the power of the working class.

Although originally presented in leaked reports to Politico and other news outlets last week as a proposal to “disband” the SRG, the mayor’s plan actually does nothing of the kind. The Strategic Response Group will not be abolished, as the mayor promised, but will instead be subsumed within the NYPD’s Intelligence and Counterterrorism Bureau. In its place the NYPD will create at least two new units specifically designed to control and suppress protest: a civilian  Community Dialogue and De-escalation Division (CDDD) and a new armed “Patrol Support Division (PSD)” to assist the CDDD with “crowd control.” Meanwhile, according to the New York Times, many of the SRG’s other tasks, including patrolling the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, will be performed by a police unit with yet another different name.

Despite all of the name changes and reshuffling, it’s clear that these new configurations are just a rebranded, perhaps slightly less lethal, but no less repressive version of the previous SRG. Armed police will still be deployed to deal with protests and the NYPD will still be allowed to use military grade weaponry, including dangerous long range audio devices (LRADs) capable of causing hearing loss and damage to disperse crowds. In an interview with ABC News on Monday alongside Mayor Mamdani, Tisch made this point very clearly: “nothing would change about the way that the NYPD responds to crowd control conditions.” How the NYPD will determine the difference between a crowd and a demonstration remains to be seen.

These changes echo a longstanding demand of our movements, from Black Lives Matter to the movement for Palestine. The problem is that they will do little to alter the balance of power between the working class and the state. Regardless of whether the SRG exists or not, the longstanding tactic of using the NYPD to manage and limit disruptive protest in order to weaken the ability of working people and the broader masses to use their collective power remains the same. The fact that we now have a “democratic socialist” mayor overseeing such repression changes nothing.

Indeed, although Mamdani has said that decisions about the NYPD are ultimately up to him, not police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, the training, staffing, and deployment of this new unit will be entirely under the direction and control of the Commissioner. Tisch, who has regularly expressed her support for the SRG, also seems to have played a central role in crafting the proposal, and there is little reason to believe that the NYPD as a whole will be any less repressive than in the past.

The proposed changes reflect a deeply-rooted hatred of the SRG, a racist, para-military like force, which has been used for years to stifle dissent and break up peaceful demonstrations. But they are also clearly a response to the widespread protests and criticisms of Mamdani that followed the shooting of Oscar Belgal by ICE agents in October.

This shows the importance of holding progressive leaders accountable, sticking to our demands, and prioritizing politics over pragmatism. However, they also reflect the limits of such pressure tactics. As the executive of the city that sits at the center of global capitalism, Mamdani’s ability to provide any concessions to the working class is almost entirely constrained by what capital and the state will allow, and as these proposals show, it ain’t much.

Ultimately, there can be no significant reform or abolition of the coercive powers of the state under capitalism. The power of the police can only be challenged through the mass organization of the working class as whole. As we saw after the huge Black Lives Matter uprisings of 2020, and the fightback against ICE in Minneapolis, people have the power to resist, to set the political agenda, and to win at least temporary concessions. But only if we remain organized and continue to build our power collectively. In the absence of a sustained and self-organized working class, with a clear independent political horizon, such gains can easily be undone.

The post Mamdani’s SRG Plan is a Classic Bait and Switch appeared first on Left Voice.


From Left Voice via This RSS Feed.