The disastrous release of the Democratic National Committee’s 2024 election “autopsy” report on Thursday has brought about a reckoning for the committee’s chair, Ken Martin, who is facing calls to resign from legislators and other influential figures in the party.
The 192-page report, written by strategist Paul Rivera in the wake of former Vice President Kamala Harris’ loss to President Donald Trump, was panned as amateurish and incomplete, even more than 18 months after the election. Rivera was reportedly fired on Friday.
Aside from being filled with glaring spelling and factual errors and containing several unfinished sections and self-contradicting annotations, it neglected key issues widely believed to have contributed to the Democratic nominee’s defeat: Most acutely, her continued backing of Israel as it perpetrated a genocide in Gaza, her inability to address working- and middle-class voters’ concerns about affordability, and the shambolic attempt by former President Joe Biden to run for a second term despite his old age and his earlier indications he would serve for only four years.
Many Democrats now see it as a damning indictment of Martin, who was elected as DNC chair last year in part on promises to conduct a thorough and transparent review of the party’s defeat. Not helping was his sudden pivot in late 2025 to attempt to bury the report he once championed, only releasing it this week after it leaked to CNN despite mounting pressure from party members.
On Friday morning, Axios quoted an ideological mix of Democratic legislators describing the report’s release as the final straw for Martin.
“He should resign,” Rep. Seth Moulton (D-Mass.) told Axios, citing “his lack of leadership” and saying it is “utterly nuts it took us this long to release the autopsy.”
In a radio interview Thursday, Rep. Mark Pocan (D-Wis.) said in response to a caller who argued Martin should be replaced: “I agree… Having what we have right now is not doing it.”
Rep. Marc Veasey (D-Texas) told Semafor that “there doesn’t seem to be a plan to turn things around and the clock is ticking… I believe it’s time for him to move on.”
Despite a push by Martin’s allies to arm state party chairs with talking points expressing that they are “fully confident in his leadership,” NOTUS reported that inside private DNC group chats and one-on-one conversations, dissension is brewing, and there is even talk of forcing a vote of no confidence to oust the chairman.
“People feel gaslit” by Martin’s flip-flopping, one unnamed DNC member told the outlet. "You kept telling people it was coming, then when you didn’t release it, you didn’t even tell everyone the real reason why.”
“While I don’t believe that there are enough votes to pass a vote of no confidence yet, I think there’s more of a permission structure now to have a more open conversation about it,” said another member who NOTUS described as an ally of Martin’s. “If they think this is going to make things go away, no, this is only going to ramp up now.”
That’s the hope of many in the party’s grassroots, who said the entire saga demonstrated Martin’s unfitness for a role with major responsibilities as Democrats head into existentially important elections in 2026 and 2028.
Dan Pfeiffer—a former Obama administration staffer whose Pod Save America podcast cohosts held Martin’s feet to the fire as he fought to keep the autopsy hidden—called the release “a disaster of his own making.”
“He didn’t pick a qualified person to run the autopsy. The fact that he was apparently shocked by the work product shows there was no oversight of the process,” Pfeiffer said on social media. “Once he saw that the report was poorly done, he just decided to start lying to everyone about why it wasn’t being released.”
“In '28, the DNC will set the primary calendar, decide how delegates are awarded, sponsor the debates, and put on the convention,” he said. “If no one trusts the DNC, it will be harder to unite the party around the eventual nominee.”
Amanda Litman, the president of Run For Something, a group that recruits progressive candidates for office, said in a video posted to social media Thursday that putting together a report composed of “pure gibberish,” without access to any of the underlying interviews or materials that buoyed its conclusions, called into question the DNC’s ability to be “a fair, competent… conductor of the Democratic presidential primary.”
“Ken Martin is not up to the task of being DNC chair—the most important part of which is preparing to run the presidential primary process with trust and competency—and should resign,” she added on Friday.
David Hogg, who served as the DNC vice chair in 2025 before being pushed out by Martin over his efforts to support primary challengers against some entrenched party elders, said the autopsy saga was a “demoralizing joke” for the party.
In a release from his political action committee, Leaders We Deserve, Hogg said, “Martin should resign, and the DNC should select a new leader who demonstrates competence, creativity, moral clarity, and a relentless commitment to actually changing the broken Democratic Party brand.”
From Common Dreams via This RSS Feed.